What are transaction costs?
Transaction costs are fees that pay for the transfer or confirmation of an exchange. While the final price already includes these costs, they aren't a part of the underlying asset's market value. Also, transaction costs don't go directly to the seller. When you pay transaction costs, the money goes to third parties (e.g., banks or brokers) that help confirm your trade.
Although transaction costs are commonly associated with fees paid in fiat currency, they can represent more abstract expenses. For instance, time, travel charges, and labor are transaction costs. A firm's expertise or legal authority could also be considered a transaction cost.
For example, a clothing business needs to account for the extra time it takes to manufacture and ship products to its store. While these "costs" may not explicitly include fees, they can impact the company's total expenses. The store owner has to factor in the time and energy spent researching and comparing manufacturers and shipping providers.
Transaction costs must occur for individuals to be incentivized to build systems we leverage to exchange value. If there was no money to be made building these systems, nobody would build them.
Types of transaction costs
There are countless examples of transaction costs, but most of these fees fall into one of three categories, which help explain the services firms provide for these fees.
1. Search and information
Search and information costs pay for services involved in finding and sharing relevant data with two parties. Brokers on exchanges such as the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) provide this service whenever they match stock buyers with sellers. Real estate agents also charge search and info fees whenever they research properties for interested homebuyers.
Buyers only need to purchase an item once they find a willing seller. During this phase, they can compare the costs of various products and negotiate their preferred rate. Third parties, such as stockbrokers or real estate agents, can charge "bargaining transaction costs" to find the best price. Comparing expense ratios at different mutual funds is an example of bargaining fees.
The third aspect of transaction fees involves legal protections and enforcement costs. Policing fees protect buyers and sellers if either party fails to meet their end of the bargain. Examples include lawyer fees and insurance payments.
Examples of transaction costs
An easy way to illustrate transaction costs is to review the real estate market. Real estate agents charge all three transaction costs at different stages of a property sale.
- First, there are title search fees when an agent has to find, share, and inspect available properties.
- Once an agent finds a home that a buyer chooses to purchase, they charge transaction fees when negotiating the final price.
- Lastly, real estate agents charge legal fees to close a transaction, which includes standard government and appraisal fees.
Although real estate sales illustrate all three aspects of transaction costs, you can find these fees in almost every financial transaction. For instance, whenever shoppers use a credit card to make a purchase, the vendor must pay transaction fees to the card provider (e.g., Visa or Mastercard). Businesses have to pay transit fees whenever they need to move their inventory. People who use a third-party website to search and book hotel rooms for travel flights also pay extra fees for using the website's services.
Stock and forex brokers charge commissions or "spread fees" to confirm trades in the investment world. Hedge fund managers and mutual funds also charge transaction and maintenance fees to manage client deposits.
When a third party confirms a transaction, chances are there’ll be an extra cost.
Why do transaction costs matter?
Inspired by the work of the 20th-century author Ronald Coase, more economists agree that transaction costs are a central aspect of financial decision-making. Before Coase published his economic theories, everyone viewed transactions as a "friction-free" experience. In this old view, buyers and sellers settled prices at a fixed and transparent price. Coase pointed out that the very process of transaction imposes unique costs on every financial exchange. In many cases, these transaction fees influence purchasing decisions more than an asset’s market price.
As transaction costs rise, customers notice more friction when buying items and services. Even if the costs of goods remain stable, high transaction costs will decrease everyone's purchasing power. As people encounter more transaction costs, consumer confidence will likely plunge.
Businesses and investors need to account for transaction costs when reviewing their expenses. If they don't factor in transaction costs, these fees could eat away their profits. Transaction costs can also impact an economy's entrepreneurial and investment activity. Low transaction costs improve people’s confidence to invest capital, while high transaction costs likely stunt economic growth.
Eliminating transaction costs
In the 20th century, economists such as Coase developed the Transaction Cost Economics (TCE) model to analyze the impact these fees have on the economy. A core tenet of TCE is that low transaction costs lead to more economic activity and efficiency. TCE supporters also believe organizations will always seek the lowest possible transaction costs.
The field of "transaction costs analysis" is designed to help businesses eliminate transaction costs. Analysts assess a company’s estimated annual expenses and put together strategies to help clients minimize these fees.
In addition to fields such as transaction costs analysis, many economists believe technological advancements will naturally decrease transaction fees. Most notably, the internet has significantly reduced transaction costs associated with search and information. Search engines such as Google find valuable information quickly and cost less. eCommerce sites and online trading platforms make it easier to connect buyers and sellers. All these innovations reduce total transaction costs.
Also, automation can reduce transaction costs for various businesses. Developments in machine learning and artificial intelligence can reduce a manufacturing plant's labor costs, which will eventually cut the transaction fees on manufacturing. In finance, many trading firms have transitioned to automated high-frequency trading machines. Those who favor these trading technologies argue they reduce transaction fees by increasing market liquidity.
While there's debate over whether new technologies will ever eliminate transaction fees, TCE economists believe lowering these costs is a net positive for the economy.
Are there transaction costs in crypto?
Although crypto doesn't have a central bank or government, you still need to pay transaction costs to transfer these coins. Blockchains such as Bitcoin (BTC) have built-in "network fees" that go to BTC miners. Since Bitcoin is a decentralized network, these crypto fees incentivize more people to use their computing power to validate BTC transactions. The higher the hash power is on the Bitcoin blockchain, the more resilient it is against hacks.
Many other blockchains, such as Ethereum (ETH), charge transaction costs known as "gas fees." Similar to Bitcoin's network fees, these gas payments go to the node operators who confirm transactions on Ethereum's blockchain.
Individuals must also pay transaction fees when using centralized crypto exchanges (CEXs). CEXs provide a centralized hub for buying and selling digital assets like stock brokerage websites. Every CEX has a different fee structure, but most charge commissions as well as withdrawal and deposit fees.
It's easy to ignore transaction costs when making small purchases, but they’re a significant aspect of the financial ecosystem. Transaction costs can directly influence all facets of the economy, including consumer habits, business development, and investment activity. However, transaction costs have declined in many areas thanks to innovations such as the internet, automation, and blockchain technology. Lower transaction fees may open up new opportunities in the global economy.
While cryptocurrencies aren't fee-free, they offer more people an affordable alternative to centralized payment services. At Worldcoin, we want more people to learn the potential benefits of crypto. To do this, we’re putting a share of our crypto in everyone’s hands for free. We're also airdropping DAI stablecoins to anyone who downloads our app. Subscribe to our YouTube channel to learn more.